27 October 2026 | Pouchforum
The EU Presidency has presented another revised compromise on the Tobacco Excise Directive, reducing proposed taxes on nicotine pouches in an attempt to overcome opposition from Sweden. However, the latest concessions will unlikely be enough to secure an agreement.
The revised text, circulated following the High Level Working Party meeting on 26 October, proposes minimum excise duties on nicotine pouches of €30/kg from 2028, €40/kg from 2030 and €50/kg from 2032. The final rate has been reduced from €80/kg, while the alternative 50% ad valorem minimum remains unchanged.
According to Bloomberg, Sweden has requested that the directive be removed from the agenda of the November ECOFIN meeting. The Presidency, however, appears determined to press ahead.
Sweden’s political uncertainty
Sweden remains without a new government following its September election. Although the centre-left secured a narrow parliamentary majority, disagreements over coalition arrangements have prevented the formation of a government. On 26 October, Centre Party leader Elisabeth Thand Ringqvist abandoned her attempt to negotiate a centrist alternative.
There is currently no clear timetable for a new government, leaving the outgoing centre-right administration in a caretaker capacity.
Nevertheless, a change of government may make little difference to Sweden’s position.
Swedish taxation has long distinguished between combustible tobacco and snus, under governments from both sides of the political spectrum.
The proposed €50/kg minimum would exceed Sweden’s current tax on traditional tobacco snus of SEK 435/kg, while nicotine pouches are currently taxed at just SEK 209/kg.
A compromise Sweden has already rejected?
According to sources familiar with the negotiations, Sweden was already offered a €50/kg minimum before the September election and rejected it.
The current caretaker government would not normally be expected to reverse such a significant policy position. Furthermore, Sweden’s negotiating position must be anchored in the parliamentary Committee on EU Affairs.
Unless that parliamentary mandate changes, the compromise appears unlikely to secure Swedish approval in its present form. EU tax legislation requires unanimity.
Could France Become an Unlikely Ally?
France’s approaching presidential election could potentially add an unexpected twist to the negotiations.
Marine Le Pen has already promised to freeze tobacco prices and end automatic inflation adjustments. With around 12 million daily smokers in France, tobacco taxation is a potentially sensitive election issue, particularly after the government banned nicotine pouches as a lower-risk alternative.
Although the proposed EU minimum would not itself require France to increase cigarette taxes, Macron may prefer to conclude the negotiations before the election rather than allow tobacco taxation to become a campaign issue.
Paradoxically, France could become an unlikely ally for Sweden. Having banned nicotine pouches domestically, Paris has little immediate reason to insist on high EU minimum taxes for products it does not allow on its market.
Further concessions to Sweden might therefore be a relatively small price to pay for securing agreement on the broader directive. If this comes to play it is truly an unexpected outcome from the completely disproportional french legislation on nicotine pouches.
